Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,508
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    joxey
    Newest Member
    joxey
    Joined

SNE "Tropical" Season Discussion 2020


Bostonseminole
 Share

Recommended Posts

8 hours ago, ORH_wxman said:

How can you even look at that satellite pic and defend a tropical storm characterization?....nevermind any flight data. 

Cranky gonna cranky. 

And he is standing by what he said and is saying with this explanation...

image.thumb.png.45f594e46bd30d2d7e8c950204834d23.png

image.png.44deaa6ece76138329b842f19221428e.png

I'm also getting a ton of backlash from his followers (some of them) for calling him out.

He did the same thing with Laura saying it would max out on Cat 2 (and weaken before landfall) when it was already Cat 3 and eventually turned high end Cat 4.

I'm curious what you have to say about his rebuttals to the criticism.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Chrisrotary12 said:

Have a feeling I am going to spark a Hadley cell diatribe, but anyone else noticing an increase in the frequency for tropical systems that slow to a crawl and/or stall between say 25 & 35 degrees?

I saw some documentation on that, but there wasn't really anything conclusive. I'm sure it will be watched going forward.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm actually more intrigued by the 'sputtering' tendency of the Basin...everywhere, perpetually - something is acting as an inhibitor .. flattening development curves. 

Any cyclone attempting to formulate in that seems to be encountering crucial thermodynamic disruptions - obviously ...otherwise, we would not have Teddy's taking 96 hours to mature through 20 kts of wind and 10 mb or pressure coring - and it is not 'SAL' alone.   

This is not just dust.  It's dry air whether there is SAL layering involved or not and it is unusual to be that pervasive. As well, its persistence suggests it is being supplied and hemispheric scope. Regardless previous week(s) orientation of dust from off of Africa ..timing those mass ejecta ...all of that. Irrelevant, because the dust dosing into each individual TC has not been the same, yet they all act to sputter, ...immediately by logic argues that the cause for sputtering is elsewhere.  

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As far as Teddy and track guidance...  wow - the models are relentless.  Just stubbornly offering zero hope it's nope! only less than climate solution can ever happen. 

Typically cyclones do not yank violently N out of 10 to 15 N latitude like the models are insisting will happen. That is supposed to be observable by this evening to 06z ... in that time frame, we should see it moving NW or even NNW if you believe in some climate-flouting guidance types, and accelerating to not only do the odd thing but to do it like they really mean it! lol

Anyway, there seems to be some sort of impermeable wall of steering conduit that has set up out there near Bermuda's longitude.  We seem to running two distinct TC seasons: one east of there, and then whatever takes place 'home grown'. It's almost like we need to keep any MDR wave flat in the troposphere ..a.k.a., weak, such that they sneak under said axis, then once west and they start developing vertical engine/mechanically, then there is hope for carnage seeking cane enthusiasts that don't think that pandemic and wild fire dystopia is enough - 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, Typhoon Tip said:

I'm actually more intrigued by the 'sputtering' tendency of the Basin...everywhere, perpetually - something is acting as an inhibitor .. flattening development curves. 

Any cyclone attempting to formulate in that seems to be encountering crucial thermodynamic disruptions - obviously ...otherwise, we would not have Teddy's taking 96 hours to mature through 20 kts of wind and 10 mb or pressure coring - and it is not 'SAL' alone.   

This is not just dust.  It's dry air whether there is SAL layering involved or not and it is unusual to be that pervasive. As well, its persistence suggests it is being supplied and hemispheric scope. Regardless previous week(s) orientation of dust from off of Africa ..timing those mass ejecta ...all of that. Irrelevant, because the dust dosing into each individual TC has not been the same, yet they all act to sputter, ...immediately by logic argues that the cause for sputtering is elsewhere.  

 

 

 

 

Everyone is spanking off to the number of storms, and that is impressive...but that is a small part of the story. I am not impressed at all when once uses ACE given the number of storms. It's barely above climo! In fact, the WPAC is quiet too and as far as northern hemi ACE goes, it is significantly below normal. There has definitely been shear, dry air...whatever over the MDR into the eastern CARB and that has hurt the quality of storms. We are almost done with the African easterly wave stuff now too. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Congenitally disabled tropical Storm Teddy RSS Feed icon Satellite | Buoys | Grids | Storm Archive
...TEDDY EXPECTED TO DEFY SEASONAL TREND TO BECOME A LARGE AND POWERFULLY IRRELEVANT MDR HURRICANE OVER THE CENTRAL ATLANTIC OCEAN IN A FEW DAYS IF EVER...
5:00 AM AST Tue Sep 15
Location: 13.7°N 46.0°W
Moving: WNW at 12 mph
Min pressure: 1001 mb
Max sustained: 60 mph
 
Public
Advisory
#11

500 AM AST
Aviso
Publico*
#11

500 AM EDT
Forecast
Advisory
#11

0900 UTC
Forecast
Discussion
#11

500 AM AST
Wind Speed
Probabilities
#11

0900 UTC
   
34-knot Wind Speed Probability
Wind Speed
Probabilities
Earliest Reasonable Time of Arrival of 34-knot winds
Arrival Time
of Winds
Wind History
Wind
History
Google Maps API Warnings and Track Forecast Cone
Warnings/Cone
Interactive Map
Warnings and 5-Day Cone
Warnings/Cone
Static Images
Surface Wind Field
Warnings and
Surface Wind
  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
  • Weenie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, CoastalWx said:

Everyone is spanking off to the number of storms, and that is impressive...but that is a small part of the story. I am not impressed at all when once uses ACE given the number of storms. It's barely above climo! In fact, the WPAC is quiet too and as far as northern hemi ACE goes, it is significantly below normal. There has definitely been shear, dry air...whatever over the MDR into the eastern CARB and that has hurt the quality of storms. We are almost done with the African easterly wave stuff now too. 

Yup that too - ...I thought of that after that post, can't forget all the observed shear.  Just look at 98L out there sitting S of the CVs over the far eastern Atlantic. Entering into the MDR, we see yet again, west ripped CB's with their vils some 200 nautical mi downstream of their of the LFC's point .. like 10 minutes after cauliflowering. 

Obviously some sarcasm there. But I've never seen that much E shear at that latitude. I mean it's like it has the same mass-transport efficiency as a westlies' jet at mid latitudes.  Really rather remarkable.

You know .. I remember back in in the 1980s as a youngin', relying upon the education that we all had to rely upon as fledgling tormented weather-souls, 'TWC' tropical update guys at 22 minutes and 52 minutes passed the hour.  Outside shooting hopes... up! be right back -   ..heh, anyway, they were always hinting statements like, 'with east flow in the tropics becoming more prevalent, we need to watch x-y-z'  ...  John Hope was one.  I bet that guy'ed roll in grave if he knew there was a Jovian wind band coming from Egyptic enchanted lands of aridity and plague.  ugh.

Yeah Chris - this is probably the under-cast of the HC working   lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought we were supposed to be in a climate heavy hit couple of decades for TC ... Maybe I have that off ?

But I thought it was supposed be a 20 to 30 years periodicity of Atl frequency.  I'll look that up the steadily declining dependability of the Internet as a veracious information source -

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's the 500 mb that's the fascinating aspect - 

It actually shows a similar evolution in principle to the Euro, just that the implication at the discrete level of impacts and results is different - time and space... Euro is weaker as a surface result, and has the dynamic mid level interplay between the cut-off and the capturing all taking place up in the Maritimes...which is probably statistically/climate-wise more likely but just comparing here..

Also, the GGEM had this sort of fusing interplay yesterday on the 12z version but lost it last night ... 

Sandy showed us that although these look outre, we cannot toss them out of hand because Sandy in fact did exactly this - although there is distinguishing if perhaps crucial difference .. in that the governing flow was heavily being instructed by a fantastic early season west-base NAO plunge that set up blocking near the lower D. Straight and sent everything into the MA including Sandy - I am not sure that is all in the cards here...  But, in a vacuum, yes...cut-offs can sometimes fuse in - 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...