Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,509
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    joxey
    Newest Member
    joxey
    Joined

February 2023 Medium/Long Range Pattern Discussion Thread.....Torch or Tundra???


Carvers Gap
 Share

Recommended Posts

The 12z CMC has nearly an identical setup.  Again, we all know this is seven days out on the CMC(not eight), and it is the only game in town.  Most of us are here during winter to track winter storms.  It sure beats tracking mid 70s(and that is on the horizon BTW).  This signal has shown up repeatedly on modeling for days to various extents.  Does it verify?  Who knows, but that is as good a signal as we have had this winter.    Could it be a mirage?  Sure.  But we can certainly enjoy tracking a potential weather event without the caveats.  We all should know them by now.  It is rare that we all get winter at the same time.  So, if this goes to middle and west TN, I celebrate for them(though I definitely pull for snow IMBY).

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The GFS and CMC diverge drastically after d7.  The 12z GFS sends the boundary to the Ohio River Valley after plentiful snow and ice across the mid and upper south.  The CMC actually depresses the boundary further and ends w/ ice in Atlanta.  Very cold air is incredibly difficult for modeling to account for.  Often it sits below 500mb, and creeps further than modeling depicts, and the CMC is a good example of that scenario. The SER is also a wild card and the GFS is a good example of that.  

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, snowmaker said:

I agree models have hitting on this timeframe. Just exactly where the boundary will be is the key. The 1st-3rd timeframe is for sure one to watch as it is in the 7-8 day range.

And ALL of it could go to the Ohio River valley.  That is plausible.   However, December is a great example of how it can go the other way - cold and dry.  I like the active STJ and cold.  That is a good combination for frozen precip in the Upper South, and even Mid-South.  Plenty can and will change, but it is worth tracking.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Matthew70 said:

Well, let’s also remember this weeks Storm was showing up on models consistently at 7 to 8 days out for the I44 area.

Indeed, I have doing this a long time, and have seen many do exactly that(bust at this range).  Busts at this latitude are plentiful regarding frozen precip.  And the -30F wind chill event was modeled well at 7-8 days out.  I have said this many times, if you want to be right 95% of the time during winter....call for rain at this latitude.  Chasing snow is risky.

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Carvers Gap said:

And ALL of it could go to the Ohio River valley.  That is plausible.   However, December is a great example of how it can go the other way - cold and dry.  I like the active STJ and cold.  That is a good combination for frozen precip in the Upper South, and even Mid-South.  Plenty can and will change, but it is worth tracking.

Agree 100%. I am feeling pretty confident that some overrunning will occur. But it could still go anywhere at this point. Really depends on the cold push. I don't think it will miss us south. More likely north. The cold could get hung up on the plateau like the last time we had one of these events. Middle and West TN scored big while it rained here in the East for days. When was that? 2021? 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No doubt you can’t take every control run to heart at 7-10 days out. I look for when models kind of latch on to the same general idea. Hopefully in the next 2-3 days we will start seeing models latch on to where this arctic boundary will set up. Looking at ensembles for that time frame is the key right now for better guidance. Like Carver was saying the boundary could be anywhere from the Ohio River to the Plateau or through central Mississippi and over the mountains. Time will tell.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Silas Lang said:

Agree 100%. I am feeling pretty confident that some overrunning will occur. But it could still go anywhere at this point. Really depends on the cold push. I don't think it will miss us south. More likely north. The cold could get hung up on the plateau like the last time we had one of these events. Middle and West TN scored big while it rained here in the East for days. When was that? 2021? 

Yeah, at this range deterministic runs will have a lot of variation.  But the signal is what I am looking for.  I am just looking for some consistency across modeling that we are in the game, and we are at this point.  I also know, that can change in a heartbeat.  I once watched 2-4'(feet is right!) modeled for Upstate South Carolina, and it busted badly even during the storm.  So, we know the drill.   LOL.   On a serious note, that amount of freezing rain could be a huge problem, especially w/ the cold which follows on the CMC.  Not quite sure I want to reel that one in......

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Carvers Gap said:

Yeah, at this range deterministic runs will have a lot of variation.  But the signal is what I am looking for.  I am just looking for some consistency across modeling that we are in the game, and we are at this point.  I also know, that can change in a heartbeat.  I once watched 2-4'(feet is right!) modeled for Upstate South Carolina, and it busted badly even during the storm.  So, we know the drill.   LOL.   On a serious note, that amount of freezing rain could be a huge problem, especially w/ the cold which follows on the CMC.  Not quite sure I want to reel that one in......

Good lord. What event was that? You hope people understand enough to factor in some climo when looking at snow maps. I don't even know if SC has ever had that much snow in their history. If that was showing on models for the valley, I would give it some serious side eye. 6 to 8 inches is usually the upper end on big events around here, with something like a foot or more being a once in a lifetime storm (like 93).

Anyways, I am a sicko and want to reel this one in. Even after having burst pipes from the last cold spell.  I can't help myself. Some men just want to watch the world bu...er umm freeze. Let's see what the Euro brings! 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Silas Lang said:

Good lord. What event was that? You hope people understand enough to factor in some climo when looking at snow maps. I don't even know if SC has ever had that much snow in their history. If that was showing on models for the valley, I would give it some serious side eye. 6 to 8 inches is usually the upper end on big events around here, with something like a foot or more being a once in a lifetime storm (like 93).

Anyways, I am a sicko and want to reel this one in. Even after having burst pipes from the last cold spell.  I can't help myself. Some men just want to watch the world bu...er umm freeze. Let's see what the Euro brings! 

I will have to go look in the SE forum.  I have an old friend who works for ESPN, and we had been discussing the big storm for Charlotte.  It definitely looked like model feedback, but if I remember correctly, most modeling had crazy amounts.  He was HOT when that one busted.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So what is the difference between the control and deterministic runs?......The storms which are bigger appear to hold the energy back long enough for the cold to drive into the forum area.  When they precip is quicker, it is more cold chasing rain.  When that energy holds back, it gets nasty.  It may also be that the cold front is stronger.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Carvers Gap said:

So what is the difference between the control and deterministic runs?......The storms which are bigger appear to hold the energy back long enough for the cold to drive into the forum area.  When they precip is quicker, it is more cold chasing rain.  When that energy holds back, it gets nasty.  It may also be that the cold front is stronger.  

So we are still looking at general trends here, none of this set in stone until at least early next week 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, matt9697 said:

So we are still looking at general trends here, none of this set in stone until at least early next week 

Yeah I've been reluctant to bite for much long range chatter this winter but the 12z GEFS has a decent cluster of similar solutions. creeping inside 200hrs.  Looks like this is a legit storm signal. Probably for points North and west of the vast majority of TN.
 

ADFC4680-65C8-4375-998B-1D8AFB5C3FCF.png.74be622c895604509fdca14636cd51ec.png
 

we can be cautiously hopeful with this GEFS mean. Emphasis on cautious lol

F46AE206-2711-4A91-A839-2A0C8534A06C.jpeg.496d89730051d50eda7cdbb994c9acc3.jpeg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, matt9697 said:

So we are still looking at general trends here, none of this set in stone until at least early next week 

I don't even know about trends at this point.  I am just looking to see where the general track cone is, and that the storm signal is still there.  I would think by Saturday, we will have a very good idea of where this is headed.  I, and some others, follow a general rule that we have to get a threat inside 150 hours to really track it.  Models are decently good enough now that sometimes we can track out to day7-9, but that has its pitfalls as we have all seen.  This is tricky business where very cold air is trying to undercut a weak HP at 500mb.  The axis is shifting hundreds of miles right now due to projections of the SER, the strength of the cold air, and number of short waves which drive the boundary.  Pretty big cone right now.  That cone decreases with each run.  Kind of like March Madness, we want to survive and advance.  For much of January, we have been in the NIT.  This is a legit pattern right now, so we just want to stay in the game with each passing model suite until this narrows the cone.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Carvers Gap said:

I don't even know about trends at this point.  I am just looking to see where the general track cone is, and that the storm signal is still there.  I would think by Saturday, we will have a very good idea of where this is headed.  I, and some others, follow a general rule that we have to get a threat inside 150 hours to really track it.  Models are decently good enough now that sometimes we can track out to day7-9, but that has its pitfalls as we have all seen.  This is tricky business where very cold air is trying to undercut a weak HP at 500mb.  The axis is shifting hundreds of miles right now due to projections of the SER, the strength of the cold air, and number of short waves which drive the boundary.  Pretty big cone right now.  That cone decreases with each run.  Kind of like March Madness, we want to survive and advance.  For much of January, we have been in the NIT.  This is a legit pattern right now, so we just want to stay in the game with each passing model suite until this narrows the cone.

 

Yea, there are so many players that make up any one storm it is amazing

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Mr Bob unpinned this topic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...