The whole start of this was around the statement that looking at analogs from decades ago may be somewhat worthless as the global pattern drivers are changing. You are arguing that N. hemisphere warming, which is changing those pattern drivers, has no effect on what we can expect in terms of winter weather in the Mid-Atlantic and that's just false. No one knows what the exact effects will be, but I'm not making that argument...
Also, I pulled data for both snow and ice cover over the past ~40 years. The warming trend is clear and it's accelerating. It wasn't me looking at the past 5. That was frd.