Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,509
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    joxey
    Newest Member
    joxey
    Joined

Fall 2022 Medium/Long Range Forecast Discussion


Carvers Gap
 Share

Recommended Posts

22 hours ago, Daniel Boone said:

Yeah, Euro continues to lag .  Could be a bias of hanging energy back, keeping trough further west. May be in the differences in their MJO projection. 

Euro during shoulder season is less than accurate for sure.  It seems to lack the ability to see cold shots.  However, the model is still usable when it does that.  Just have to see only when he warmth backs-off, and usually that is when BN temps move through.  

Its seasonal is very warm for winter.  Even though it is biased warm and it is shoulder season, its solution is plausible. We actually have not had a "stinker" of a winter in some time west of the Apps.  Generally, we have had a storm or two that drops some white stuff(Chattanooga excluded).  There are, however, winters in TN where it snows very, very little at all lower elevations.  We are long overdue for one of those.  That said, I think we see some extreme cold at some point west of the Apps.    Base-warm winter pattern though looks to be likely - QBO, solar, IO, and Pac are bearish for sustained cold after December.  But who knows?  Recent climo patterns don't really follow the rules the mid-late 20th century.  Winter has already set-in out West and is right on time.  This also fits Nina climatology.  IMHO, December is our best shot, maybe early January.  

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, Carvers Gap said:

Euro during shoulder season is less than accurate for sure.  It seems to lack the ability to see cold shots.  However, the model is still usable when it does that.  Just have to see only when he warmth backs-off, and usually that is when BN temps move through.  

Its seasonal is very warm for winter.  Even though it is biased warm and it is shoulder season, its solution is plausible. We actually have not had a "stinker" of a winter in some time west of the Apps.  Generally, we have had a storm or two that drops some white stuff(Chattanooga excluded).  There are, however, winters in TN where it snows very, very little at all lower elevations.  We are long overdue for one of those.  That said, I think we see some extreme cold at some point west of the Apps.    Base-warm winter pattern though looks to be likely - QBO, solar, IO, and Pac are bearish for sustained cold after December.  But who knows?  Recent climo patterns don't really follow the rules the mid-late 20th century.  Winter has already set-in out West and is right on time.  This also fits Nina climatology.  IMHO, December is our best shot, maybe early January.  

Excellent points Carver's . Glad you posted those. 

     Odds do favor milder than avg. for particularly the eastern forum obviously as the Pac is a big Driver. Solar definitely not good either. As mentioned many times, and we all basically know, what we need to alter the canonical Nina Pattern is a formidable -NAO. Saw a post on MA Forum about 2 Winter's with similar aspects as this Nov. irt pattern and indexes.  Analogues; 1978-79 and 85-86.

      Both were good Winter's snow wise here . Both featured dominant blocking. 78-79 was a record cold one for the Nation as a whole. Every continental US State was below average except for Maine and Florida !

      85-86 featured slightly below avg Temps here with above average Snowfall. Area's SE of us were above average Temperature. Incidentally, it was a third Year Nina as well. Great Analogue. 

     

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Holston_River_Rambler said:

Griteater has some early morning winter thoughts this AM:

 

If ever there was going to be an outlier(Grid references those), it is this year.  Why?  Climatology has been wonky for the past 4-5 years - almost doing the exact opposite of analogs at times.  I believe this has to do with the temperature gradient in the Pacific being for uniform that stratified during ENSO events(reference one of the guys in New England for that...TyphoonTIp I believe).    I do think the mean trough will be centered in the western Plains and Mountain West w/ intrusions into the East.  This warm November is gonna flip hard to BN temps I believe.  If it does that, I think the La Nina pattern is likely going to be a traditional sequence of BN/Seasonal December -> early cold shot January -> WARM February and and early end to winter.

2023-2024 I am about as bullish as one can be.  -QBO, weak El Nino after 3 La Ninas, Pacific SST gradient reset after this cold episode(should accentuate the El Nino response here)....loaded for bear.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Carvers Gap said:

If ever there was going to be an outlier(Grid references those), it is this year.  Why?  Climatology has been wonky for the past 4-5 years - almost doing the exact opposite of analogs at times.  I believe this has to do with the temperature gradient in the Pacific being for uniform that stratified during ENSO events(reference one of the guys in New England for that...TyphoonTIp I believe).    I do think the mean trough will be centered in the western Plains and Mountain West w/ intrusions into the East.  This warm November is gonna flip hard to BN temps I believe.  If it does that, I think the La Nina pattern is likely going to be a traditional sequence of BN/Seasonal December -> early cold shot January -> WARM February and and early end to winter.

2023-2024 I am about as bullish as one can be.  -QBO, weak El Nino after 3 La Ninas, Pacific SST gradient reset after this cold episode(should accentuate the El Nino response here)....loaded for bear.

Just dont want no  freaking split of the SPV.Last few decades when we get the SSWE and it splits our winters are garbage,might be different this time if it does but lately it hasnt been.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, jaxjagman said:

Just dont want no  freaking split of the SPV.Last few decades when we get the SSWE and it splits our winters are garbage,might be different this time if it does but lately it hasnt been.

Yeah.  SPVs tend to favor EurAsia.  When we do get the split (and equatorial push of Arctic air) in NA, it favors the west.  We have had some really good winters with the SPV and some really craptastic winters.  The year with the Memphis sub-zero, multi-day snow storm...that was a good SPV split if I remember correctly.  Seems like we do well with maybe 1/4 to 1/3 of splits.  If we want winter to continue into Jan/Feb this year, we may need one.  The positive QBO lends itself to less blocking.  Nina should help early on, and hurt us later on....Right now, looks to me like we are setting up for a mid-Nov to late Dec cold shot, and then we could be done with the exception of thread-the-needle stuff.  That early season cold pattern(potential...not certain) should not be related to the SPV, though admittedly I haven't looked at stratospheric stuff much at all in about 2 weeks.  That thing could be on fire right now, and I wouldn't know.  LOL.  Then, Nina climatology should send the trough into the Mountain West during Jan/Feb - where it is now actually.  So, if the SPV trough normally goes there anyway and Nina has it in the Mountain West anyway, I am for taking a 1 in 4 shot in splitting it and sending it eastward mid to late winter.  Again, I think the rising QBO really argues against blocking after December.  QBO should flip back to a more favorable cycle next August or so.  But some winters don't behave.  A third year La Nina is a total crapshoot in the meager analog packages available for that rare occurrence.

You guys have had some great recent winters in middle TN.  Knoxville has done OK as well.  The closer one is to the Apps, the less these past Nina winters have been helpful re: snow.  I think you all get one more potentially good winter before the ENSO pattern switches up to one which favors coastal tracks next winter as Nino takes hold.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, jaxjagman said:

Just dont want no  freaking split of the SPV.Last few decades when we get the SSWE and it splits our winters are garbage,might be different this time if it does but lately it hasnt been.

Ha! Ha! Man, you have a to tell me when you know a split is coming.  I had heard rumors and just looked at the 18z GFS due to your comments.  Textbook split.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, not sure I want to see a SSW and subsequent SPV/TPV split that early.  Now, if one wanted a wall-to-wall cold winter...those can start that way.  I don't see that happening BTW.  OTH, we could see our early cold December dump westward (climo says eastward in December), and we could see DJF go warm.  Man, I am kicking myself for not seeing that.  The massive warm-up along the East Coast is often a pre-cursor to big SPV splits.  

Mega kudos to Jax for point that out.  Hope you are doing well, man.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hadn't even looked yet at SPV stuff this early. Just looked at it this AM and yeah its getting thwacked around even this early. When was the last one we had in Nov/ Dec? 

At 50mb the Euro gets a good N. European ridge going in about 7 days:

TCisfej.png

 

GFS goes on to get a pretty good split at that level through the end of its run:

giphy.gif?cid=790b7611e490fc9c06492ae5f0

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess it's that time again, lol. 

The Euro's take on the MJO is pretty classic La nina:

p8MmAXl.png

It hits the phase 8 area and it's like, "ohhhh noo, can't go there, back to 5, 6, and 7." I do remember that when we have it hang round in 6 in high amplitude it can favor the sort of SPV split the models are showing is possible. 

 

Soon I'll have to go look at Anthony Masiello posts about Siberian night jets and other such things, lol. 

 

 

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, Holston_River_Rambler said:

I guess it's that time again, lol. 

The Euro's take on the MJO is pretty classic La nina:

p8MmAXl.png

It hits the phase 8 area and it's like, "ohhhh noo, can't go there, back to 5, 6, and 7." I do remember that when we have it hang round in 6 in high amplitude it can favor the sort of SPV split the models are showing is possible. 

 

Soon I'll have to go look at Anthony Masiello posts about Siberian night jets and other such things, lol. 

 

 

We are gonna be fighting the MJO all winter the the IO and dateline SST setup.  Probably going to be in the warm phases all winter as a generality.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Holston_River_Rambler said:

I hadn't even looked yet at SPV stuff this early. Just looked at it this AM and yeah its getting thwacked around even this early. When was the last one we had in Nov/ Dec? 

At 50mb the Euro gets a good N. European ridge going in about 7 days:

TCisfej.png

 

GFS goes on to get a pretty good split at that level through the end of its run:

giphy.gif?cid=790b7611e490fc9c06492ae5f0

Is there a 3-D animation of it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This helps explain the incoming cold pattern. High press eastern Siberia plays nicely with the AK 500 mb ridge forecast on models. Snow cover is also AN (Rutgers map not shown).

Note snowcover is worthless without pressure context. Low press / high snow is stormy and mild. High press high snow sets the table for cold if it's delivered. 

Looking ahead, models don't keep the cold pattern long. However it bears watching. If the cold hangs in longer than a couple weeks, it could be the November preview of winter deal. Of course a quick strong mild recovery may also be a winter preview.

We'll know more after the Champions Classic Novie 15th, because college basketball has all the answers, haha!

 

image.png.9bbfb54432ac0e52862b24da12359906.png

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, nrgjeff said:

This helps explain the incoming cold pattern. High press eastern Siberia plays nicely with the AK 500 mb ridge forecast on models. Snow cover is also AN (Rutgers map not shown).

Note snowcover is worthless without pressure context. Low press / high snow is stormy and mild. High press high snow sets the table for cold if it's delivered. 

Looking ahead, models don't keep the cold pattern long. However it bears watching. If the cold hangs in longer than a couple weeks, it could be the November preview of winter deal. Of course a quick strong mild recovery may also be a winter preview.

We'll know more after the Champions Classic Novie 15th, because college basketball has all the answers, haha!

 

image.png.9bbfb54432ac0e52862b24da12359906.png

Great post ! 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, nrgjeff said:

This helps explain the incoming cold pattern. High press eastern Siberia plays nicely with the AK 500 mb ridge forecast on models. Snow cover is also AN (Rutgers map not shown).

Note snowcover is worthless without pressure context. Low press / high snow is stormy and mild. High press high snow sets the table for cold if it's delivered. 

Looking ahead, models don't keep the cold pattern long. However it bears watching. If the cold hangs in longer than a couple weeks, it could be the November preview of winter deal. Of course a quick strong mild recovery may also be a winter preview.

We'll know more after the Champions Classic Novie 15th, because college basketball has all the answers, haha!

 

image.png.9bbfb54432ac0e52862b24da12359906.png

Thanks Jeff for this. Great analysis as always.  I do think we may actually see more of a pronounced pattern change in December but this is a warning shot.  I could be wrong though...

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Carvers Gap said:

We are gonna be fighting the MJO all winter the the IO and dateline SST setup.  Probably going to be in the warm phases all winter as a generality.  

Sure looks that way. Best we can hope for is it stays rather low amp in the warm phases but, that's not too likely. 

     Hopefully another Driver can knock things off kilter. There are a couple things that have a chance but odds are stacked against them being dominant for any sustainability. 

     The rising QBO is a big concern imo . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 12z GFS does not have a long term, strat split.  BUT, the strat is on fire even as it reconsolidates.  There is an equatorial displacement of cold air d10-15 on the GFS.  Is it right?  I don't know.  Looks like two stout, cold air masses are depicted on it.  At this point, that looks like our first winter-storm window.  Yeah, I know it is November.   That said, that pattern is ripe for a storm -> cold, GOM open for business.  Likely will be more of a cutter, but if one of those 1040+ highs presses south it will displace the storm track southward in response.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Mr Bob unpinned this topic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...