Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,586
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    23Yankee
    Newest Member
    23Yankee
    Joined

Atlantic Tropical Action 2011 - Part IV


Recommended Posts

It appears eager to get raped by shrederola.

@ Hr114

lokos pretty much ilke the last run maybe a touch stronger by 132 hitting eastern hispaniola. lol.. panel by panel d10+ threats. :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

All four runs on Monday showed it. All four runs on Tuesday showed it and both runs this morning showed it. Is my math off? This run makes it 11 if it shows up.

By my count, Mapgirl looks foolish now with the trolling.

I actually wasn't trolling. The way you came into the thread and annouced it was now 10 made it seem you have seen the run early, hence the question to IAN about it...since you know, he also made a comment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I actually wasn't trolling. The way you came into the thread and annouced it was now 10 made it seem you have seen the run early, hence the question to IAN about it...since you know, he also made a comment.

the original number was 9 prior to 12z gfs.. which has not finished to be called. but the whole debate is a little silly imo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the original number was 9 prior to 12z gfs.. which has not finished to be called. but the whole debate is a little silly imo.

Of course it's silly - but you know, god forbid I make any comment related to OEM otherwise I'm trolling.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All four runs on Monday showed it. All four runs on Tuesday showed it and both runs this morning showed it. Is my math off? This run makes it 11 if it shows up.

By my count, Mapgirl looks foolish now with the trolling.

Oh, I got you. However, based on my notes, I don't have a hit from the 0Z Mon run. Maybe I missed it? Do you have any details about that run and/or a saved map from it you can post?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fixed

Folks probably should wait until a storm is named before even considering any GFS post day 5 outputs as meaningful even with consistent output run to run.

If the Euro starts to show similar output as the GFS as consistently, then I'll raise an eyebrow.

Right now, there has been only one run of the Euro even remotely close. The one prior to it had it being shredded Emily style.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The GFS hugging is just a sign of desperation for a decent storm, it seems, which is mildly understandable but quite silly, too.

I disagree, other models show this, not just the GFS and it has been my experience tat the very large majority of situations in the past where there has been this many runs of various models showing some sort of development we at least get a depression out of it- I think that chances of that are well over 50%.. Now whether it is a hurricane, or it actually hits the US are very much in question, but I think that there will probably be a TC of some sort.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fixed

Folks probably should wait until a storm is named before even considering any GFS post day 5 outputs as meaningful even with consistent output run to run.

Actually... Not sure I agree.

Trying to discern the intensity and landfall point of a tropical cyclone ten days out is absurd. But gaining some general takeaways from the runs-- like, "The pattern for a mainland hit is improving" or "Conditions across the NATL might be improving"-- is perfectly reasonable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If the Euro starts to show similar output as the GFS as consistently, then I'll raise an eyebrow.

Right now, there has been only one run of the Euro even remotely close. The one prior to it had it being shredded Emily style.

100% agree, until Dr No shows a consistent tight isobar low heading East I am totally unimpressed by modeling. That being said that is one helluva major broad circulation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree, other models show this, not just the GFS and it has been my experience tat the very large majority of situations in the past where there has been this many runs of various models showing some sort of development we at least get a depression out of it- I think that chances of that are well over 50%.. Now whether it is a hurricane, or it actually hits the US are very much in question, but I think that there will probably be a TC of some sort.

Oh no doubt that there is a high chance of this becoming a TC at some point... the issue is the obsession over "10 US hits in a row"... in a quite distant time frame on a model that has been questionable at that range... when this could just as easily be Emily Part II over Hispaniola.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

100% agree, until Dr No shows a consistent tight isobar low heading East I am totally unimpressed by modeling. That being said that is one helluva major broad circulation.

Not to steal Ed's thunder, but I never trust any intensification in the GFS after the resolution chop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree, other models show this, not just the GFS and it has been my experience tat the very large majority of situations in the past where there has been this many runs of various models showing some sort of development we at least get a depression out of it- I think that chances of that are well over 50%.. Now whether it is a hurricane, or it actually hits the US are very much in question, but I think that there will probably be a TC of some sort.

Well said.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree, other models show this, not just the GFS and it has been my experience tat the very large majority of situations in the past where there has been this many runs of various models showing some sort of development we at least get a depression out of it- I think that chances of that are well over 50%.. Now whether it is a hurricane, or it actually hits the US are very much in question, but I think that there will probably be a TC of some sort.

Actually... Not sure I agree.

Trying to discern the intensity and landfall point of a tropical cyclone ten days out is absurd. But gaining some general takeaways from the runs-- like, "The pattern for a mainland hit is improving" or "Conditions across the NATL might be improving"-- is perfectly reasonable.

I think we can agree that some sort of organized LP complex will be on the map as most models point to that. Silly to project either way anything else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually... Not sure I agree.

Trying to discern the intensity and landfall point of a tropical cyclone ten days out is absurd. But gaining some general takeaways from the runs-- like, "The pattern for a mainland hit is improving" or "Conditions across the NATL might be improving"-- is perfectly reasonable.

Which should be taken with a grain of salt after seeing the modeled/actual paths of 92L.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh no doubt that there is a high chance of this becoming a TC at some point... the issue is the obsession over "10 US hits in a row"... in a quite distant time frame on a model that has been questionable at that range... when this could just as easily be Emily Part II over Hispaniola.

The Hispaniola factor is silly to speculate about ten days out. Hispaniola is a relatively small target and obviously the modeling this many days out is going to be course. I don't even know why people mention factors like Hispaniola ten days out.

What matters is that the GFS (and other models) take a significant cyclone much further W than anything we've seen this year or last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh no doubt that there is a high chance of this becoming a TC at some point... the issue is the obsession over "10 US hits in a row"... in a quite distant time frame on a model that has been questionable at that range... when this could just as easily be Emily Part II over Hispaniola.

Just about all models have been quetionable this year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...