I would take a rerun of the last 2. 16-17 was meh, but pretty much median snowfall here, 17-18 was right at mean, which is about all anyone should ever hope for. Both had a chaseable big snowstorm/blizzard an hour away.
eta- I shall clarify, since somehow @Eskimo Joe has gotten confused, Rerun of 16-17 and 17-18. Last time we had back to back Ninas.
Winter of 18-19 was not a Nina. It was the Nino fail, aka puny Nino.