i posted my thoughts on this in banter. there was nothing wrong with the long range thread. if everyone utilizes the panic room and banter threads appropriately, then the actual weather threads would improve. part of the fun is when the long range thread spawns its own storm threat. some banter in all threads is probably fine, but meltdowns should go in the panic room and beer discussions should probably go in banter, etc.
the other option is to go back to the way it was, but maybe having a separate thread for very long range/teleconnections.