It really depends on how one measures the winter.
I feel like there’s been a shift on the forum in grading winters. Early on with WWBB and EUSWX, everyone judged winter solely on inches of snow. Doesn’t matter when or how, if on April 1st you had X-inches relative to normal, that was that.
Many still do that, I generally find that snowfall is what you look back on as a single number. Like in 30 years, snowfall will be the quick and dirty look.
Maybe it was because back on those forums we had mid-Atlantic folks with us, but snowfall inches was the holy grail to grade a winter...and ratter had to be a very specific snowfall amount to be counted. One storm can take a place quickly out of ratter territory even if the rest of winter does nothing at all.