I won't agree or disagree. But there's a few factors here -
There's a difference between asking a meteorologically relevant question and asking "How much for Philly?" in a fast paced discussion thread.
I was an AWFUL poster in the Eastern days back in 2006. I posted too much, opined on things I had no clue what I was talking about, and did too much hand wringing over storms. I started reading, listening to met posts, and not feeling like I had to be posting to stay relevant.
We just all need to be friendly towards each other and give new posters friendly nudges if needed. But if somebody keeps up terrible posting - I have no issues with the mods 5-posting or taking other action.
The vast majority of people on here are friendly and willing to teach newbies.