This happened once before, I believe 2007. WWA was eventually upgraded to an ice storm warning in places. I believe that is the last time we had one in the NYC warning area outside of maybe Western Passaic.
12z Euro gets extreme NNJ and the Hudson Valley below freezing by 12z. That's the key. It actually trended 1-2 degrees colder at this hour than the 00z run.
How much of the rain actually freezes on contact really depends on intensity and surface temps.
The 3k NAM has most of Northern Bergen and Southern Rockland sitting between 28 and 30 degrees when the heaviest is falling. Would think you would get pretty good accretion at those temps.
12z RGEM which has always been on the warmer side.
It actually has quite a long period of ZR but the precip isn't as intense as some of the other guidance.