I am with you. Track was more or less exactly where I thought.. however, I seemed to have significantly overestimated the top winds.
That withstanding, I would argue that I - you especially- was not quite as far off as it would look. The energy within this storm was quite impressive and had this tightened up just a bit more, Cat 2 would have been easily hit, perhaps even high end Cat 2. As you said, 12 more hours and well...