Just busting.
I'm with you, it is very fascinating to see why the two camps are drastically different. My opinion on AI model aside (since ultimately my opinion means nothing), this is a tremendous opportunity within the field of forecast modeling and obviously the only way to ever see the true value in AI and how helpful will be is by putting it to the test. If the AI score a coop here that would not only be a tremendous win in the AI department but it probably also further exposes significant weaknesses in the traditional modelling.
On the other hand, if the AIs fail here, then at least to me, signifies the importance of physics and complex equations and that there is much more to the evolution of weather than just on how a 'similar match' evolved historically.