Without traffic - door to door its a bit under 2 hrs 50 mins. Worst part of the drive is the few minutes on the Beltway to get into MD and 270. After that, its usually smooth sailing, especially 68 which never has traffic unless there’s an accident.
When we bought the house five years ago, we got it to rent out. But we quickly realized how much we enjoy being there (and get out there ~2 weekends/month plus longer trips around the holidays/summer) - so we’ve never rented it out since the thought of renting it to randoms and then using it a week later skeeves me out (YMMV). My stress level immediately declines the second we get there which is another reason why I love to get there.
I think you’d really like a place in Canaan since I know you enjoy hiking/snow/breweries/etc - I’d imagine its probably under 3 hours from you too.