My rating would probably be far too generous due to this being my first winter in New England, all of my past winters spent in the pathetic south.
Positives:
+Consistently in the 20s and 30s with the rare "warm" days being in the 40s, rarely 50s
+Snow on the ground a substantial portion of the season.
Negatives:
-No real snowstorms, snow on ground was from successive smaller events.
I'd give this a darn good rating, but as I said, I'm biased. I just can't even begin to describe how refreshing this winter has been for me. It may not have been a true New England winter (apparently), but it's night and day from what I dealt with before. Much, much more in line with how a winter should be, so much better for my mental health.