I'm not sure what the synoptic setup was like in the 1880s, but for 1974, the pattern just hasn't been conducive for that type of storm in the central/western Great Lakes.
For most of the epic/historic snowstorms in this region (see Buffalo last month for example), they required deep closed upper level lows, a negative tilt trough, no greenland block and a surface low with gulf origins.
The closest things came was 2/26/13. But thermals were an issue for that system.
Until we can shake up the upper level flow so that it's not so damn uber-progressive, it's going to be awhile.