There's two predominant storm tracks, one goes to the north of us and the other to the south of us. NYC is in a bad place for west to east type tracks (or even southwest to southeast tracks unless they slope just right), we need coastals that are offshore-- but not too offshore. Which means we need phasing. But not too much phasing too early....
So NYC is much more thread the needle than other places, both north and south of us even in a "good" pattern.
It's why places both south and north of us often do better with snow....and also the fact that the ocean is to the south which is much worse than having it to your east (also bad for summer heat, which I love.)