I don't know. I don't really have a good answer for that. But all I know is there have been many instances of being burned, even inside this range because of discounting models or solutions and for various reasons. Some of the reasons include; 1) Because the solutions aren't showing what we want, 2) the solutions go against original thoughts, 3) it is very difficult to separate emotions from a forecast
I'm speaking from personal experience here but there have been way too many times I jump on the "big snow" train because the NAM and/or GFS + ensembles are coming in hot and heavy...the Euro isn't quite there but "I'm expecting it to come aboard". So I go big on the snow. Then as guidance starts to collapse, I let emotions get in the way of reality and I try and look for anything...something that justifies the snowier scenario, even though its clear and evident its not happening.
Yesterday I thought this was going to be a pleasant surprise and even today I've made some posts saying I think a foot could be possible where the heaviest banding occurs. And I can sit here now and try to find anything...something to justify that and just run with it because it fits my motive...but the reality is that just isn't there.
When it comes down to it we just have to ask ourselves, in this type of setup, what warrants a solution which is more amped versus less amped? Off all the pieces at play here, historically what is the outcome? IMO, how quickly that front drops south and east is going to be huge. The more amped solutions are slower with the south and east progression of the front but it is from my brief experience that guidance can often be too slow with this...this would leave me to believe that amped/northwest is not as likely. I am also very nervous with the indications of the stronger convection well off the mid-Atlantic and that playing some role. This is something which has been discounted in the past but often times becomes a bit player.
Too many flags right now and if we expect there will be some last minute miracle...well that doesn't happen often