I haven’t posted in a little while and have been watching this storm develop but have a couple of things to say:
1) models (GFS guilty as charged) have proven to show their bias in developing these CAG systems too quickly. Clearly it’s taking this time to organize, and imo that was expected and models showing this jumping straight to a hurricane were out to lunch
2) the development signal overall track guidance has been EXCELLENT. I mean it’s been DAYS and the general idea of development and movement haven’t changed and that’s before we even have a named system
3) intensity forecast is… problematic at best. The ULL to the west and a trough interaction on approach are significant variables that are difficult to forecast. If aligned improperly, both features could impart shear on the system both as it develops and also as it heads towards the coast. However, as the ULL retrogrades NW, it could leave a window with an extremely favorable environment and explosive SST. Models are extremely split on how this interaction plays out.
4) I would not take eastern tracks off the table quite yet. The ULL I spoke to earlier is what pulls this westward. The further east this forms, the less of an influence that system will have. Ian is an example where models greatly overestimated the interaction with a ULL in the western GOM and yea, let’s just say those track forecasts were way off. That being said, guidance is extremely and I mean extremely clustered for there being a COC. I guess this is just directed to say not to let your guard down across the entire west coast of Florida.
5) Stop the hype. This isn’t pointed at this forum, but the hype level this storm has received is off the charts. I’ve seen extremely tempered weather folks on social media throwing out HAFS runs showing a 888 catastrophe for Florida while failing to post the 975 cat 1/2 from the next run. Extremely respected Mets seemingly have slurped the kool aid on this one and I can tell you it’s unlike any storm I’ve ever seen before from a social media perspective, considering it’s not even a tangible named system yet.