I wish there was more detailed records of some of these historic winters in the 1800s. Nothing has ever come close to how snowy some of them were. And I'm not sure why? Not sure if theres stations in Michigan, Ohio, or Illinois that go back that far?
Even from a temperature standpoint and not just in winter, but yearly. Not sure if its a result of UHI, but a lot of the summers in the 1800s in Toronto were cold by today's standards only averaging around 68 (+/- 1.5).
However, some of the numbers at YYZ are questionable for some winters especially 07-08. Every station in Toronto recorded 90-100" that winter with YYZ only at 76". Consequently YYZ fell short by 5" from breaking the all-time record (1938-39). Similar story with 08-09. YYZ recorded 60" but most stations were 70+".