We chose Canaan because we love everything about the Valley. Dolly Sods, hiking, fishing...it's got everything. And the new ownership at Timberline is fantastic. We will move there permanently in a few years. The downside is if you need a special tool, part etc you're an hour to either Oakland, MD or Elkins. Sucks when you are doing a project and have to drive an hour for a carriage bolt (don't ask me how I know)
It's also a very small town, everyone will know your name.
If you are looking for something small, Black Bear resort often has 1 or w 2 BRs that are somewhat reasonable by today's standards.