Probably a question of semantics....if we have a similar autumn, to say, 1971....but we end up like 0.3F warmer or something....I would classify it as correct to say "we've had autumns like this before".....if the record is smashed by like 2 degrees, then that would be a more dubious statement.
FWIW, only BOS out of the first-order stations in SNE is currently having their warmest autumn on record...and their temps are running a bit "questionable".