Yes I was really disappointed on the 2nd day of the Dec 2003 storm because I expected a HECS on the level of Jan 1996 and it never got quite that good. It snowed lightly throughout the day and was nothing like the first day of the storm, even though it was much colder.
That's when I learned that colder temps dont necessarily mean more snowfall lol.
How much did EWR get in total? Anything like the 20 inches across Central Long Island?
Does that sort of remind you of the last March 2018 storm that also jackpotted Central Long Island with 20 inches of snow?
That Jan 2011 storm was hall of fame worthy because all the snow that fell in the first part of the storm had melted already and we somehow still got to nearly 20" in about 5 hours of snowfall! I remember thundersleet and even a tornado reported just south of Long Island (waterspout) just before the second part got underway, at the tail end of the rush hour.
FWIW that might have been actual hail and not thundersleet at the start of the second part of that storm!