Usually you take a blend. It worked out last weekend.
There is a reason the NWS heavily leans on the NBM (national blend of models).
The NBM does not contain the ICON, but it does contain the UKIE and Euro. Here, the synoptic pattern with respect to the primary matters alot with respect to the mid-levels, so the GFS has more weight than normal when it comes to mid level warming, etc.
When track is the same, follow the Euro/Mesos for thermals. When the synoptics differ, then GFS gets more weight than usual in my book. Its picking up on the earlier transfer and other models have been trending that way as well. Once the models agree more on the development of the secondary, the GFS thermals go out the window and we lean on the mesos.