Dec 1989 was probably a bit better in the southern mid-Atlantic. I know the South had several good storms that month.
But as some others pointed out, front-loaded winters are inherently disappointing since they end so early. I think the one I remember most clearly is 2003-04. Started with a great December storm (especially in the colder burbs), had a very cold January and another good storm late that month, but then the rest of the season was a total shutout. I was very disappointed that February had no measurable snow at all, and of course March wasn't much better... I think it had a dusting at the most.
Still a pretty good winter overall, but the premature end definitely left a bad taste in my mouth.