Farther north we had similar 2m temps and precip - rates & total - but accreted maybe 0.25". Must've been a skinnier cold surface layer.
In the Jan 1953 ice storm in NNJ that probably triggered my interest in trees and weather, every tall tree near our home at 700' lost branches, often most of them, and a few trees snapped like breaking a pencil. (Noisier, though) In the next town, 2-3 miles north and 300' lower, it was mainly a cold rain. Hilltops above 800' had numerous "asparagus trees", naked stems with the lost branches piled around the base. It was nearly as severe as Jan 1998 though far far smaller in extent, limited to the hilly country N and W from NYC.