Not that surprised. Your area seems to for whatever reason always be the jackpot in the NYC metro area in marginal events.
I’m not surprised Boston got almost nothing because of that second low in CT.
Some of it is the UHI warming effect in terms of in and right near the city but a lot of it with this particular storm seems to be better dynamics in terms of precip north and east of NYC although sorta surprised to hear even some places in Central NJ got accumulation since they were even further from the low than NYC.
Probably gonna need to either really pick up in intensity or last until after sundown to get anything in NYC. Right now not that optimistic.
Obviously a different story north and west which could see several inches on the grass.