You can't really go wrong over there either. Rumble woods accessed from the top of Middle Earth is absolute prototype steep eastern trees and small cliffs, and even the trail itself premier Vermont cut narrow moguls down the fall line. Ellen summit is a little more exposed with scrubbier trees as you pointed out. So if it's foggy or especially windy you're better off elsewhere. Also, sometimes after a big storm, they might hold off on opening Ellen an extra day. But if you hit it right, especially on a bluebird, I don't think you'll wish you had splurged on the LP ticket.