1992 wins that but barely. The difference in regards to the wind when comparing 1992 and 2010 was the wind direction (SE in 2010 and NE in 1992) and much shorter duration of the strongest winds in 2010.
Maybe they're right and it's not. I happen to think they should have upgraded and it should be a Cat 5 currently. The nutty posts are flying right now though.
Thank you for posting in the proper thread.