Looks perfectly seasonable to me for the metro. Mid to upper 60's most days (maybe some 70's in there) with lows in the 40's. Can't get much better for October.
So as of right now EWR isn't even in the top 20 for 90 degree days.
Also pretty insane that 1993 had nearly as many 95 degree days as we do 90 degree days this year. Now that's hot.