Could be an interesting study one day. I think it's debatable which aspect of all of this caused the most suffering, fear, and dread at a national level. The concern over the risk of dying or a loved one dying from COVID versus the impact of shutdowns, business closures, school closures, and general economic decline. It's a complex problem.
I do believe there is very little appetite nationally for more shutdowns over COVID, and an attempted second round of them will get ugly.