Vergent,
In the way you presented this comment and your concluding sentence directed at Skier, you are implying that the scientists you listed were effectively signatories to the AMEG's position statement.
However this isn't at all clear from the acknowledgements on the AMEG site. You omitted a crucial part (highlighted):
So, advice was sought and obtained from these individuals, but it doesn't necessarily mean that they fully support the AMEG's objectives and share the same concerns.
Is there another page on the site that I've missed where it makes it clear that all these scientists are members of the AMEG?
