Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,502
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    Weathernoob335
    Newest Member
    Weathernoob335
    Joined

March 2020 disc/obs


Torch Tiger
 Share

Recommended Posts

44 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

I knew it helped.l with traction. But I thought most got away from sand due to the environment issues it causes. 

The sand does temporarily help with traction, but after 30 cars or so go over it, depending on speed, there is no sand left in the wheel paths.  I have done a lot of work on this for CT and as chloride levels in ground water continue to increase, it is amazing to me how many people think of the good ole days of sand not realizing that there was salt mixed in with it.  Without the salt, it would have frozen in the back of the truck.  

The sand is an environmental headache as they clog rivers and streams and generate hundreds of thousands of tons of sweeping that need to be disposed of which is not a cheap or simple problem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, dryslot said:

Sodium Chloride (salt) is more environmentally unfriendly then sand, Calcium is next as it will eat your car frame as well as fuel and brake lines, Besides the fact that from about 5°F or below, Salt is useless on roadways hence the mix with sand.

I think the mix on highways is 16:1, enough salt to encourage melting if temps aren't too cold.  On the logging roads it's 50:1, just enough to keep the sand from freezing, as melting is undesirable.  Only used on hills and bad curves; the straight and level is for hauling fast and heavy.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Connecticut Appleman said:

The sand does temporarily help with traction, but after 30 cars or so go over it, depending on speed, there is no sand left in the wheel paths.  I have done a lot of work on this for CT and as chloride levels in ground water continue to increase, it is amazing to me how many people think of the good ole days of sand not realizing that there was salt mixed in with it.  Without the salt, it would have frozen in the back of the truck.  

The sand is an environmental headache as they clog rivers and streams and generate hundreds of thousands of tons of sweeping that need to be disposed of which is not a cheap or simple problem.

Yes. Sand is as bad if not worse environmentally than salt. There’s a reason why even 25 years ago NY state only used salt 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, tamarack said:

Dixmont hills are indeed snow catchers, and other things as well.  In March 1984 the communications towers atop the hill collected 4-6" of ice and many didn't survive.  I think that area also affects the 160s section of I-95 where so many crashes occur.

As for sand vs all salt, if I'm driving during the storm I prefer sand - the liquid salt just makes things more slippery.  If I'm coming 12+ hours after final flakes, the salted road is apt to be a lot nicer. 

I saw those towers up there. I googled and it looks like they’re about 1300’. Just driving thru there seeing the topography and East/west facing hills I could tell that’s a weenie spot 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Connecticut Appleman said:

The sand does temporarily help with traction, but after 30 cars or so go over it, depending on speed, there is no sand left in the wheel paths.  I have done a lot of work on this for CT and as chloride levels in ground water continue to increase, it is amazing to me how many people think of the good ole days of sand not realizing that there was salt mixed in with it.  Without the salt, it would have frozen in the back of the truck.  

The sand is an environmental headache as they clog rivers and streams and generate hundreds of thousands of tons of sweeping that need to be disposed of which is not a cheap or simple problem.

Yeah we use sand almost exclusively at the ski resort but then we take the huge snowbanks at end of season and push them back into the parking lots to melt, to recollect the sand.  We then have a lot of heavy equipment sweep and collect the sand, which then gets reused the next winter.  There are numerous catch basins too to keep runoff sand from reaching the waterways.  It’s a pretty expensive program though with a ton of man hours to clean up properly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, powderfreak said:

Yeah we use sand almost exclusively at the ski resort but then we take the huge snowbanks at end of season and push them back into the parking lots to melt, to recollect the sand.  We then have a lot of heavy equipment sweep and collect the sand, which then gets reused the next winter.  There are numerous catch basins too to keep runoff sand from reaching the waterways.  It’s a pretty expensive program though with a ton of man hours to clean up properly.

VT is really strict about runoff into steams and brooks. Anytime you come near a stream you have to have containment plans and silt screening. It seems to me that most sand is used on dirt roads Though some is used during ice events

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, powderfreak said:

Yeah we use sand almost exclusively at the ski resort but then we take the huge snowbanks at end of season and push them back into the parking lots to melt, to recollect the sand.  We then have a lot of heavy equipment sweep and collect the sand, which then gets reused the next winter.  There are numerous catch basins too to keep runoff sand from reaching the waterways.  It’s a pretty expensive program though with a ton of man hours to clean up properly.

Is it just a cost thing? It just seems with the $$$ Stowe has and generates, the last place that should be using sand is them. That’s mind boggling. I recall as a kid , I grew up in Vernon on a cul de sac. My dad hated the sand they’d dump and would go out with a broom, shovel and wheelbarrow and clean up the whole thing. I guess it’s no shock why I’m so OCD. I just cannot stand the sand and grit getting inside the vehicles, on the mats, staining shoes . I shake out the mats every time I get in. I just couldn’t believe they were still using it so extensively up here. I’m in Portland now at Sebago brewing after checking into hotel and I don’t see any sand here .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

Is it just a cost thing? It just seems with the $$$ Stowe has and generates, the last place that should be using sand is them. That’s mind boggling. I recall as a kid , I grew up in Vernon on a cul de sac. My dad hated the sand they’d dump and would go out with a broom, shovel and wheelbarrow and clean up the whole thing. I guess it’s no shock why I’m so OCD. I just cannot stand the sand and grit getting inside the vehicles, on the mats, staining shoes . I shake out the mats every time I get in. I just couldn’t believe they were still using it so extensively up here. I’m in Portland now at Sebago brewing after checking into hotel and I don’t see any sand here .

I’m sure it’s a state thing.  Given the volume of material they need to put down in the parking lots and resort roadways, I’m not sure all that salt going into the local waterways is any better.  At least with sand they can contain it with silt catch basins and various methods.  I mean the spread for traction every single day all winter.  

My guess is it is something the state of VT  has told them to do vs just the cheapest method.  Like hey you can put all this sand down and then use a ton of money to pick it back up.  I think sand is more costly as they spend weeks cleaning it up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

Is it just a cost thing? It just seems with the $$$ Stowe has and generates, the last place that should be using sand is them. That’s mind boggling. I recall as a kid , I grew up in Vernon on a cul de sac. My dad hated the sand they’d dump and would go out with a broom, shovel and wheelbarrow and clean up the whole thing. I guess it’s no shock why I’m so OCD. I just cannot stand the sand and grit getting inside the vehicles, on the mats, staining shoes . I shake out the mats every time I get in. I just couldn’t believe they were still using it so extensively up here. I’m in Portland now at Sebago brewing after checking into hotel and I don’t see any sand here .

You won't get to bang all of the 160+ Micro Breweries up here but it sounds like you been to a few of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, dryslot said:

You won't get to bang all of the 160+ Micro Breweries up here but it sounds like you been to a few of them.

Dude.. if I lived here.. I’d be broke, fat and liver less. The amount of good beer here is sick. This place was 2 minute walk from hotel. It’s valet only parking, so I didn’t have a choice really but to walk and eat. Cool place here 

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

Dude.. if I lived here.. I’d be broke, fat and liver less. The amount of good beer here is sick. This place was 2 minute walk from hotel. It’s valet only parking, so I didn’t have a choice really but to walk and eat. Cool place here 

The old port is a great place especially in the summer, Been to Sebago Brewing, Bissell Bros, Maine Beer Co, Flight Deck, Allagash, Bear Bones and i could go on and on, It doesn't end.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

Dude.. if I lived here.. I’d be broke, fat and liver less. The amount of good beer here is sick. This place was 2 minute walk from hotel. It’s valet only parking, so I didn’t have a choice really but to walk and eat. Cool place here 

How do you function drinking so much? I can drink a few good beers one night, get a little silly, but then not even look at one for another month or two. I have some in my fridge from the last play date my kids had...the saturday before the SB. No desire. I guess I’m just not a big drinker, it’s a waste of carbs too. 

  • Weenie 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, RUNNAWAYICEBERG said:

How do you function drinking so much? I can drink a few good beers one night, get a little silly, but then not even look at one for another month or two. I have some in my fridge from the last play date my kids had...the saturday before the SB. No desire. I guess I’m just not a big drinker, it’s a waste of carbs too. 

Vapes, Tinctures, Edibles and Beers oh my.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, powderfreak said:

I’m sure it’s a state thing.  Given the volume of material they need to put down in the parking lots and resort roadways, I’m not sure all that salt going into the local waterways is any better.  At least with sand they can contain it with silt catch basins and various methods.  I mean the spread for traction every single day all winter.  

My guess is it is something the state of VT  has told them to do vs just the cheapest method.  Like hey you can put all this sand down and then use a ton of money to pick it back up.  I think sand is more costly as they spend weeks cleaning it up.

Recycling sand on roadways is just about impossible as traffic running over it tends to round the sand particles which makes it act like marbles and does not help as much with traction.  It also creates a ton of very fine particles which turns to mud.

Sand/salt mix works well on gravel roads - particularly right after application as the dissolution of the sodium chloride is endothermic (absorbs heat) and can cause the road to ice up temporarily.

Every state has different application rates, but the use of straight salt does increase the amount of salt used some, but it is not as much as most people think, since the salt in the sand was doing the work for snow and ice removal so you just had to apply a lot more material to get the desired affect.

When CT switched from a sand/salt (de-icing) mix on state roads to all salt (anti-icing), the number of crashes occurring on roads with snow, slush or ice was significantly decreased.  The idea of anti-icing is preventing the bond of the snow pack to the pavement which ultimately requires less salt to get the pavement bare at the end of the storm.  The idea is to maintain a layer of brine between the snow and the road.  For salt to be "melt snow", it needs to be a brine - dry salt does not affect ice.

And for what its worth - salt (sodium, calcium or magnesium chloride) does not damage asphalt pavement.  The same can not be said for Portland Cement concrete.

I will apologize for the dissertation on winter operations - it is something that I have spent a lot of time on.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...