I think part of the problem we are seeing with the lp locations, has to do with the fact that this big ball of energy is just dropping in from the NNW. Normally with a bowling ball system like this it rolls in from the 4 corners and so pops an initial low in TX or the Gulf, but this system already has a surface low dropping in and so as the energy makes the turn, that low gets confused ( I know its not alive, but hear me out) wrt which boundary to jump to. Does it jump up into the eastern TN valley? Does it jump down to the toasty Gulf coastal waters? Does it stay near its energy? And while all this is going on, the system is moving, so pretty soon the Gulf stream becomes an option too.
I think we want this energy to drop in so far south that there is never a doubt about where the low pops: the Gulf. I wish I knew more about the physics and meteorology of surface low formation so I could convince myself that the warm Gulf waters would override these other options.